So, hey everyone, annoyance is not a feminist issue. Unless your annoyance is at the patriarchy and the manifestations thereof, it is not a feminist issue. It is a personal issue. Believing that your personal annoyances about any and everything are Issues that should be Discussed is a function of privilege, plain and simple.
Now this is not an argument against the idea that the personal is political, which is something I strongly believe is true. This is an argument against the tendency of hyper-educated, upper middle class, privileged, [generally] white women to pervert that concept and make it into precisely the kind of individualistic, special snowflake bullshit that feminism is supposed to stand in opposition to. The phrase is meant to imply that individual instances of suffering under oppression are political issues. It matters if someone uses a gendered insult at me. It matters if a man touches my body without my permission. It matters if school administrators don’t take it seriously when I am harassed in the hallways, or if my boss turns a blind eye when a misogynistic comment is made in a company meeting. These things are personal to me, and they are political, as they are part of the system of oppression in which my life is conducted.
By the way, in case we have all completely taken leave of our senses, now might be a good time for a little refresher on another concept I thought was integral to feminism: that suffering one form of oppression does not mean you suffer all forms of it, that you understand how all the forms of it function, or that you cannot also be part of a system of oppression that other people face. Let’s take for example the fact that I am a woman in a sexist society. The patriarchy oppresses me as a woman. I am oppressed by sexism and its perpetrators. That doesn’t mean that everything that ever goes on in my life is oppressive to me. I am not oppressed by my car running out of coolant. I am not oppressed by a measuring cup falling into the space between the sink and the fridge in the middle of a baking project. I am not oppressed when the coffee maker at work takes forever to heat the water before producing the first pot of coffee on a Monday morning. I am annoyed – as hell, sometimes – at these things. But none of them are oppressive, which is why you don’t see me taking to the internet to write 83 paragraphs about them in a space that is designated for discussion of the actual oppressive systems of which I am a victim.
I’m also not fucking oppressed when someone’s behavior annoys me, especially if that person is a member of a class of people who are in fact oppressed by a class of people to which I belong. I am a woman. I am also an adult. Children are members of a group of people who are oppressed by the group of people – adults – to which I belong. (You might be the kind of complete jackass who doesn’t get that children are oppressed and controlled by adults, but if so, you should probably hit the highway right now, because I will never waste my time educating you about that, and I will also never allow comments arguing against this extremely obvious fact.) Before anyone gets their boxers up their ass, I’m not comparing or ranking oppressions. The condition of being a child under a system of adult control does not equate one-to-one to the condition of being a woman under a system of male control. No two oppressions are identical, but the fact remains that being oppressed in one circumstance does not render one incapable of being oppressive in another. I also subscribe to the theory that one cannot be oppressed in a situation where one is the oppressor – that is, men can’t be oppressed by me, I can’t be oppressed by non-Christians, and … listen closely… children cannot oppress me as an adult.
So when a kid behaves annoyingly, I am annoyed. (Likewise, magically enough, I feel those same feelings when an adult behaves annoyingly. Imagine!) I am not oppressed. It is not a matter of discussion for an anti-oppression group when a kid raises her voice in a bookstore where I’m browsing at lunch. Because no one was oppressed. In fact, if we’re going to talk about it in an anti-oppression framework at all, we should actually be talking about what the least oppressive way is to handle the kid’s voice-raising. Any childfree hipster assholes who might be stupid enough to be hanging around my blog might snort derisively at this idea, and that’s fine. Sometimes when my kid was showing her ass back in the ass-showing toddler years, I snorted derisively at the idea of doing anything other than snatching her up, taking her out of whatever situation we were in where she was annoying the fuck out of other people, and very loudly reading her the riot act. It’s a common reaction. It’s oppressive and controlling, but it’s very common, and I’m not judging individual parents for it. I did it all the time when the kid was a toddler. I did an updated version of it this very morning when she pulled some maddening seven-year-old nonsense on me. It’s not that it’s not understandable, it’s that there’s nothing interesting or radical or feminist or anti-oppression about it, and therefore it doesn’t make for a particularly feminist or anti-oppression conversation topic.
The point is, children are human beings. My daughter, in fact, is a woman (albeit a tiny one right now), making her kind of the ideal candidate for membership in feminism. (Except she’s a working class person of color, and from what I can tell anymore, at least the feminism represented on the internet couldn’t give less of a fuck about people in those categories, either.) If we’re concerned about tearing down systems of oppression, we should be raising people who recognize it, reject it, and feel empowered to fight against it. I’m not saying I am perfect at this. My own parenting fails this test every single day. But I try. I think about it. I don’t pretend the moments in which I silence my daughter, control her expression, or make her feel like she’s a burden on me or other people are shining moments in our relationship. I fucking certainly do not pretend that they are explicitly feminist moments. They are just moments when I react in the way we are taught – by the same fucking patriarchal influences that teach us how to oppress other groups of people – it is okay to react when an annoyance is coming from a child (which is usually wholly different from how we would ever react if an adult annoyed us). There’s nothing special about it. There might not really be anything egregiously wrong with it, and my kid will probably survive it all just fine, but I’m not going to be a fucking hypocrite and pretend that these are moments when I’m applying feminism, and I’m never going to ask feminists to validate my knee-jerk annoyed reactions and call them feminism. Maybe they’re not unfeminist (and, uh, they probably are), but they’re certainly not especially feminist, and they don’t belong in a feminist discussion. Feminism is not the space where we trade tips on how to better control other human beings or air our irritation about how people we’re actively oppressing are behaving toward us… or at least that is quite seriously NOT what the fuck I signed up for when I CENTERED my identity on feminism for all of the most important years of my adulthood. I was looking to have my way of thinking challenged, top to bottom, and to divest of my privilege and my own oppressive viewpoints and reactions.
Just… for fuck’s sake! Am I really having to write this down? Are we [privileged American feminists] this self-centered and fucking stupid? Has feminism become so focused on personal choice and personal fee-fees that we can’t fucking employ basic logic to keep us even marginally on task? Are we so infected by the toxic scourge of individualism that our brains are just fucking rotting now?
I feel like this is pretty basic, but if a major feminist blog with writers who are viewed and called upon as the philosophy’s scholars are too fucking dense to put it together, maybe it needs repeating, not that any of those people read this. But maybe someone who pops in here because of the rageful comment I made over at Feministe will see this in a new way, or maybe they already see it this way and will just know that at least one other person thinks that the kid-bashing (and, for crying out loud, mama-bashing) in feminist space is disgusting. So. Lean in to your screen and read this shit real closely. Telling an entire huge segment of the human population that you are disgusted by them and they need to shut up so you don’t have to hear them is not consistent with resisting oppression, which is what feminism purports to be about. Publicly pressuring the caregivers of these people to oppress and control them more for your personal comfort is not consistent with resisting oppression, even if you insist that it’s just for a little while until they reach an age at which you will find them acceptable and deserving of inclusion in your anti-oppression efforts. Conducting that pressuring under the guise of an anti-oppression movement? Calling your own oppressive bullshit anti-oppression? Calling it feminist? Never mind the inconsistency; never even mind the Orwellian hilarity of it; it’s just fucking sickening. Among myriad other reasons I feel less comfortable in a feminist identity with every passing day, this shit makes me want to give the whole goddamn thing a big, loud, bookstore-peace-disrupting Fuck You.